Top 5 Things to Know When Choosing a Birth Injury Lawyer
A plain-language guide for Alberta families
If your child or a loved one has suffered a birth injury, the decisions you make in the weeks that follow can shape your family's future for decades. One of the most important decisions is choosing the right lawyer — and not all lawyers who advertise birth injury experience are equal.
Many lawyers in Alberta (and from outside the province) advertise that they have extensive experience in birth injury and medical malpractice litigation. However, advertising and actual experience can be very different things.Here are the five most important questions to ask before you decide who will represent your family.
What Trial Experience Do You Actually Have?
This single question is what separates true medical malpractice lawyers from general personal injury practitioners. Before hiring anyone, visit their website and look specifically for trial decisions they have been involved in — not just settlements.
Do your own research: You can search a free Canadian legal database called CanLII (canlii.org). Put the potential lawyer's last name in quotation marks in the keyword search field and see what trial decisions come up. It takes five minutes and tells you a great deal.
Why does trial experience matter so much? There are two big reasons.
REASON 1 — THESE CASES GO TO TRIAL MORE OFTEN THAN YOU THINK - Medical malpractice cases go to trial far more often than other civil cases. If your lawyer has never run one, defence counsel will know it — and they may push your case all the way through a trial, counting on that inexperience working against you. If you end up in a courtroom, you want a lawyer who has been there before and knows exactly what they are doing.
REASON 2 — SETTLEMENT DEPENDS ON THE THREAT OF TRIAL - Even if your case never sees the inside of a courtroom, the defence must believe your lawyer is both able and willing to run a full trial if a fair settlement isn't offered. A lawyer without credible trial experience loses that leverage entirely.
Does Your Lawyer Practice Regularly in Alberta?
Lawyers from other provinces — particularly Ontario and British Columbia — frequently advertise for birth injury cases in Alberta. Many of them are highly experienced medical malpractice lawyers in their home province. But "experienced" does not always mean "right for your Alberta case."
The rules that govern how civil lawsuits are conducted vary considerably from province to province. An out-of-province lawyer who is unfamiliar with Alberta's procedural rules could cause delays, miss important steps, or — in the worst case — harm your claim in ways that are di#cult to recover from.
BEYOND THE RULES — IT'S ALSO ABOUT CUSTOM
Every province has its own customs around how these lawsuits are conducted in practice: how expert witnesses are retained, how examinations for discovery are managed, how negotiations typically unfold. A lawyer who is deeply familiar with how things work in Alberta can move your case more smoothly and quickly — and in some situations, that familiarity can be the difference between a successful settlement and a stalled case.
Ask a prospective lawyer directly: "How many birth injury or medical malpractice cases have you handled specifically in Alberta in the last five years?" The answer will tell you a lot.
Is this lawyer's practice genuinely focused on medical malpractice?
This is a point that often gets overlooked. Some law firms handle everything from car accidents to slips and falls to medical malpractice — birth injury cases are one of dozens of case types on
their list. Others have built their entire practice around medical negligence cases.
Birth injury cases are genuinely complex. They require a network of specialized medical experts, a deep understanding of obstetrical standards of care, and a familiarity with how these cases move through Alberta's courts. A lawyer who handles medical malpractice as a small fraction of their caseload will not have the same depth of expertise as one who has dedicated their career to it.
QUESTIONS TO ASK:
- What percentage of your practice is medical malpractice?
- How many birth injury cases do you take on each year?
- Do you have existing relationships with obstetrical and neurological experts?
The answers will quickly tell you whether this lawyer will be a true specialist in your corner — or a generalist learning on the job.
Has the lawyer been independently recognized by Lexpert or Best Lawyers?
Any lawyer can describe themselves as experienced or highly skilled on their own website. Independent legal rankings are different — they represent recognition by peers and rigorous third-party research, not self-promotion.Two of the most respected legal ranking organizations in Canada are Lexpert and Best Lawyers. Being listed in either is meaningful, and here's why it matters to you as a client.
WHAT IS LEXPERT?
Lexpert is Canada's leading legal directory, published annually. Rankings are based on peer surveys — meaning other lawyers, including defence counsel and fellow plainti" lawyers, rate eachother on expertise and reputation. A lawyer who is consistently ranked by Lexpert in medical malpractice has earned the respect of the broader legal community, not just their own marketing team.
WHAT IS BEST LAWYERS?
Best Lawyers is one of the oldest and most widely recognized peer-review publications for the legal profession in the world. Selection is based entirely on peer nomination and evaluation. Being listed in Best Lawyers in Canada in the area of medical malpractice is a meaningful signal that the lawyer is regarded by colleagues as genuinely accomplished in the field.
When researching potential lawyers, check whether their profile on the firm's website mentions these recognitions — and be specific. A ranking in personal injury is not the same as a ranking in medical malpractice. You want a lawyer who has been recognized specifically for the type of work you need.
How to verify: Search both directories directly at lexpert.ca and bestlawyers.com. Look up the lawyer by name and confirm they appear under a medical malpractice or health law category — not just general litigation or personal injury.
Does the firm have the financial resources to properly fund your case?
This is the question almost nobody thinks to ask — and it may be one of the most important ones.
Birth injury and medical malpractice cases are extraordinarily expensive to prosecute properly. Before a single argument is made in court, a well-prepared case typically requires retaining multiple highly specialized medical experts: obstetricians, neonatologists, pediatric neurologists, neuroradiologists, life care planners, and more. Each of these experts charges significant fees — not just for their opinion, but for reviewing thousands of pages of records, writing detailed reports, and testifying at trial. In complex birth injury cases, the cost of expert witnesses alone can run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
WHY THIS MATTERS FOR YOUR CASE
Medical malpractice defence teams — typically funded by the Canadian Medical Protective Association, one of the best-resourced defence organizations in the country — will retain their own roster of top experts. If your lawyer cannot match that level of expert preparation, you are going into the fight at a structural disadvantage. A case that is under-resourced is a case that is harder to win, and harder to settle well.
THE PROBLEM WITH SMALL FIRMS AND LARGE GENERAL INJURY FIRMS
The economics of birth injury litigation don't work for every firm. A small boutique firm may simply not have the capital to carry hundreds of thousands of dollars in disbursements over the two to five years a case can take to resolve. On the other end of the spectrum, large personal injury firms that focus on high-volume, lower-complexity cases — car accidents, slip-and-falls — often operate on a business model that depends on quick turnover.Slow, expensive, expert-heavy medical malpractice cases don't fit that model well, and may not get the investment they require.
The firms best positioned to properly fund birth injury cases are those that have built their entire practice — and their business model — around medical malpractice litigation. They carry the costs, retain the right experts, and have the infrastructure to see a complex case through to the end without cutting corners.
QUESTIONS TO ASK:
- How does your firm fund disbursements, including expert fees?
- How many experts do you typically retain in a birth injury case?
- Have you worked with obstetrical and neonatal experts before, and do you have established relationships with specialists in these fields?
The answers will tell you whether this firm is genuinely equipped — or whether your case might be quietly under-resourced down the road.
Choosing the right lawyer after a birth injury is one of the most consequential decisions your family will make. The stakes — for your child's future care and your family's financial security — are simply too high to leave to chance.
Take your time. Ask the hard questions. Use the CanLII tool to verify trial experience. And don't hesitate to consult with more than one firm before deciding.
If you have questions about a potential birth injury claim in Alberta, we offer free, confidential consultations with no obligation. We're here to help you understand your options — with plain language and genuine care.
BOOK A FREE CONSULTATION
We assess your case at no charge. If we believe there is not enough substance to proceed, we will tell you — and we will not charge you for the time spent reviewing your file.
Speak with an experienced birth injury lawyer today. (780) 424-2030
TELL US ABOUT YOUR CASE